BREAKING: Makinde ‘Loses’ At Appeal Court - 247Updates
Connect with us

Politics

BREAKING: Makinde ‘Loses’ At Appeal Court

Published

on

The Court of Appeal in Abuja, on Friday awarded N50 million in damages against Governor Seyi Makinde of Oyo State, and six others for failure to pay the outstanding balance of N3,374,889,425.60 (N3.4 billion) from the N4,874,889,425.60 (N4.9 billion) debt, arising from a May 7, 2021 judgment of the Supreme Court.…CONTINUE READING

A three-member panel of justices, in a unanimous judgment, condemned Makinde’s conduct, which it described as disrespectful of the nation’s judicial system.

The court affirmed the April 27 decision of the High Court of the Federal Capital Territory, FCT, ordering the state governor to paid the outstanding balance.

The N4.9 billion debt arose from the judgment of the Supreme Court given against Makinde, the state’s Attorney-General (A-G), Accountant-General and four others in an appeal by chairmen and councillors elected on the platform of the All Progressives Congress (APC), but sacked on May 29, 2019, by Makinde, upon assuming office.

In the judgment, the appellate court upheld the arguments by the lawyer to the ex-council chiefs, Musibau Adetunbi, SAN, resolved the two issues, identified for determination, against the appellants and dismissed the appeal filed by Makinde and six others for lacking in merit.

Advertisement

The court awarded N50 million cost against Makinde and co-appellants, to be paid to the ex-council chiefs led by Bashorun Mojeed Bosun Ajuwon.

The judgment was on the appeal marked: CA/595/2023 filed by Makinde, the Oyo State’s A-G, the Commissioner for Local Government and Chieftaincy Affairs, Accountant-General of Oyo State, Speaker of Oyo State House of Assembly, the House of Assembly and Oyo State Independent Electoral Commission, OYSIEC.

In the lead judgment, Justice Danlami Senchi held that, as against the contention by the appellants, there was no dispute in relation to the amount that constituted the judgment debt.

The judge referred to a letter written on Dec. 13, 2021, by the A-Gof Oyo State, where the state put the salaries and allowances due to the ex-council chiefs at N4,874,889,425.60 and pledged to pay everything within six months.

Advertisement

He said the court could not allow Oyo State Government and its officials to approbate and reprobate; blow hot and cold at the same time by claiming the amount constituting the debt was not ascertained despite the letter by the A-G and the fact that the appellants took steps to settle the debt by making part payment.

Justice Senchi also faulted the appellants’ contention that the ex-council chiefs failed to first obtain the consent of the Oyo State A-G before initiating a garnishee proceeding to seize the state’s funds to settle the judgment debt.

The judge said asking the ex-council chiefs to first seek and obtain the consent of the Oyo A-G, who was one of the judgment debtors, amounted to making him to be a judge in his own case, “which requirement is unfair to the judgment creditors.”

“The ex-council chiefs were in order to have initiated the garnishee proceeding, because there was a judgment debt to be paid by the appellants by virtue of the judgment of the Supreme Court,” he said.

Advertisement

The Supreme Court had, in its May 7, 2021 judgment, declared the action of the ex-council chiefs, who sued through 11 representatives, led by Bashorun Majeed Ajuwon, as lawful and ordered the Oyo State Government to compute and pay them their entitled salaries and allowances within three months of the judgment.

Rather than comply with the judgment, the Oyo State Government paid only N1.5 billion, prompting the judgment creditors (the ex-council chiefs) to initiate a garnishee proceeding against Makinde and others before the High Court of the FCT.

In the April 27 ruling, Justice A. O. Ebong of the High Court of the FCT issued a garnishee order absolute, directing Makinde and others to pay the balance of the judgment debt on instalment basis, begining with N1,374,889,425.60 to be paid immediately.

Justice Ebong ordered them to subsequently pay the remaining N2b billion at N500 million quarterly, with the first instalment payable on July 31, a decision Makinde and others challenged at the Court of Appeal.

Advertisement

It was the April 27 ruling by Justice Ebong that the Court of Appeal affirmed in the judgment delivered on Friday.
Post Views: 84

Grab This Opportunity Now👇👇👇

    
 
   
Continue Reading
Advertisement
Advertisement
Breaking News1 hour ago

Massive Crowd Recorded As NLC Nationwide STRIKE Begins (PHOTOS)

Politics1 hour ago

BREAKING: Reps reacts to alleged plan to create six more states

Breaking News2 hours ago

BREAKING: Nigerian Girl Wins Qur’an Recitation Competition In Jordan

Breaking News2 hours ago

BREAKING: Court Restrains Telecom Operators from Deactivating Unlinked SIM Cards in Nigeria

Politics2 hours ago

BREAKING: President Tinubu Unveils Monthly Stipend Plan for Unemployed Nigerian Youths

Breaking News2 hours ago

5 Top Bandit Leaders, 48 Fighters Killed in Deadly Zamfara Clashes

Breaking News2 hours ago

BREAKING: Despite Competition, We’ll Make Our Cement, Food Products More Available, Affordable, Accessible To Our Customers – BUA Group Chairman

Breaking News2 hours ago

Kanika Tekriwal: Cancer Survivor to India’s Youngest Jet Tycoon with $50.61M Empire

Politics2 hours ago

BREAKING: Why I introduced contributory pension – Obasanjo

AFCON3 hours ago

Mauricio Pochettino can’t win Chelsea titles and signing Mykhailo Mudryk should be a sackable offence, says Darren Bent

AFCON3 hours ago

Chelsea stars appear to scream at Mykhailo Mudryk immediately after Virgil van Dijk goal

AFCON3 hours ago

Reporter shares news from within Chelsea as Pochettino sack decision made

AFCON3 hours ago

Pochettino at ‘serious risk’ of sack as Chelsea line up Premier League boss to replace him

AFCON3 hours ago

Sergio Aguero will start training with former team this week ahead of stunning football return

Entertainment3 hours ago

“I Have Never Hold This Kind Of Money In My Life, My Children Negleected Me, But You Show Me Love”- Mama A2 Breakdown In Tears As Kunle Afod Surprises Her With 645k (Watch)

Entertainment3 hours ago

“See as u fresh, chai that thing dey good for your body “Fans reactions as Mercy Aigbe share cute photo with her husband, Kazim Adeoti

AFCON4 hours ago

He is a waste of money,I don’t know where Pochettino went to buy Him from,He killed our game last night’: Thiago Silva Blames ONE Chelsea for their disappointing loss yesterday

AFCON4 hours ago

Enzo Fernandez review why he fights with 24-year-old Chelsea teammate after Liverpool cup defeat

AFCON4 hours ago

He will be a monster if He joins Chelsea,if I’m to be Guardiola I will make sure I highjack the deal as soon as possible to avoid competition’: Ian Wright blown away by 21-year-old who Chelsea reportedly want to sign

Breaking News4 hours ago

Meet The Man Who Had 39 Wives, 94 Children And 33 Grandchildren

Breaking News4 hours ago

BREAKING: FG to ease loan disbursement to MSMEs

Breaking News4 hours ago

BREAKING: Naira gains as CBN plans $40,000 weekly sales to BDCs

Politics4 hours ago

BREAKING: Cleric Who Called For Killing Of Remi Tinubu Apologises

Breaking News4 hours ago

BREAKING: Naira Strengthens on US Dollar Across FX Market Segments

Breaking News4 hours ago

BREAKING: Gunmen kill village head, two policemen and 11 others in Nasarawa

AFCON4 hours ago

It’s hard to say,but I think this is time to say Goodbye’: Chelsea start mudryk sends His emotional farewell message to Chelsea fans as He is set to join Rival club in the summer

Health4 hours ago

Ways To Last Long During Sex

Breaking News4 hours ago

BREAKING: Ortom, Suswam, Moro, Oche, others attend PDP Stakeholders Meeting in Makurdi [PHOTOS]

Breaking News4 hours ago

BREAKING: Full list of agencies, commissions, parastatals to be scrapped, merged, relocated, subsumed

Breaking News4 hours ago

BREAKING: Federal Government Conditions for N50bn Grant

Breaking News2 days ago

Lady With The Heaviest Nyãsh in The World Forced To Buy Two Plane Tickets At Airport — See Who How She Struggled To Enter The Plane

Breaking News2 days ago

BREAKING: Nigerians Blame Sunday Igboho For Buhari’s Swollen Legs, Reactions Trail

Health16 hours ago

Stroke kills fast: reduce your consumption of these 4 things if you want to live long

Breaking News23 hours ago

Rumble in RCCG as Pastor Adeboye Asks City of David Pastor to Resign Amidst Wigwe’s Death

Breaking News2 days ago

My Husband CHEATED On Me With My Best Friend, So I want to Cheat Him Back To Feel The Way I Did – Regina Life Experience

Health1 day ago

What are the signs of heart disease?

Relationship23 hours ago

Never Tell a Woman These 4 Things, It Will Hurt Her So Much

Relationship24 hours ago

3 Secrets That You Should Never Tell Your Wife No Matter the Situation

Health2 days ago

Breakfast: 15 Foods You Should Never Eat In The Morning

Health1 day ago

Effective Home Remedies To Heal Menstrual Cramps

Health1 day ago

6 Effective Ways to Relieve Back Pain

AFCON4 hours ago

He is a waste of money,I don’t know where Pochettino went to buy Him from,He killed our game last night’: Thiago Silva Blames ONE Chelsea for their disappointing loss yesterday

AFCON4 hours ago

He will be a monster if He joins Chelsea,if I’m to be Guardiola I will make sure I highjack the deal as soon as possible to avoid competition’: Ian Wright blown away by 21-year-old who Chelsea reportedly want to sign

Health1 day ago

Boost Your Immune System With These Effective Methods

Health1 day ago

3 Reasons Why You Should Have Morning Intercourse Regularly With Your Partner

Breaking News22 hours ago

CBN Removes over N1trn Excess Cash from Access Bank, Zenith, Others To Fix Naira Fall, Inflation

Breaking News22 hours ago

White woman gives birth to a Black child, says her great-great-great grandparent was Black, and the child took after them [VIDEO]

Health15 hours ago

I ignored these cancer symptoms for years because I was scared – now I could die within months at 31

Health1 day ago

STDs Increasing Among Nigerian Youths – Foundation

AFCON1 day ago

Meet 8 Brothers Who Play Football For Different Countries

Health2 days ago

Best Anti-Cancer Foods: Top 5 Superfoods Most Recommended by Experts

AFCON2 days ago

Breaking New: ”Warning” Chelsea owner Todd boehly review why Pochettino will be sacked if possible he loses the final against Liverpool today

Health15 hours ago

Experts say there is no need for gaps in the mouth | Health Focus

Breaking News22 hours ago

Girls try to run out on restaurant bill, but had to come back because they left their car keys [VIDEO]

Health1 day ago

Positive Effects Of Apple On People With Low Sèx Drive

Health1 day ago

Baby Dove Teams Up With Black Owned Birth Justice Organization To Expand Doula Services To Black Mothers

Politics2 days ago

BREAKING: Nigerians will Never stop Suffering & Pains, Fact is that Nigeria’s Oil Production Is 1.7M Barrels per Day While the Same Quantity Is Stolen Every Day – Former President Obasanjo

AFCON2 days ago

BREAKING: Osimhen scores again for Napoli

Politics23 hours ago

BREAKING: President Bola Tinubu Appoints Billionaire Business Leaders to Tackle Naira Depreciation

Breaking News2 days ago

BREAKING: UNILAG Student Buys Rice at Massive Discount of N10k from Customs, Shares Experience with Soldier

Trending